7 Best Small Business Insurance in New York for 2024

Sections of this topic

    Navigating the complex landscape of small business insurance in New York can be a daunting task for entrepreneurs. With diverse options and regulatory requirements, securing the right coverage is crucial for protecting your business against unforeseen challenges. 

    This article offers a comprehensive guide to understanding the various insurance available for small businesses in the Empire State. It highlights the cost of small business insurance in NY and essential tips from professional companies like Next to ensure your business remains safeguarded and compliant. 

    Whether you’re just starting out or looking to reassess your current policy, this resource will equip you with the knowledge to make informed insurance decisions tailored to your unique business needs.

    >> Explore Next for Comprehensive Coverage >>

    What Business Insurance Is Mandatory in New York?

    State laws influence business insurance requirements in New York, and certain policies are mandatory in all areas, from Rochester to New York City.

    Workers’ Compensation Insurance

    This insurance is essential for all businesses with employees, whether full-time or part-time, in New York. It covers medical expenses for work-related injuries or illnesses, such as a cleaning company employee getting sick from fumes. Workers’ comp also provides disability benefits and shields business owners from liability related to workplace injuries.

    Commercial Auto Insurance

    Any vehicle owned by a business in New York must have commercial auto insurance. This type of policy covers accident-related costs involving business vehicles. The minimum requirements for auto liability insurance in New York are:

    • Bodily injury coverage stands at $25,000 per individual
    • Each accident’s bodily injury limit is $50,000
    • Should a death occur, coverage per individual is $50,000
    • Death coverage per accident hits $100,000
    • Property damage per mishap is capped at $10,000
    • Personal injury protection amounts to $50,000
    • Uninsured motorist coverage provides $25,000 per person
    • Uninsured motorist protection per accident is $50,000

    Trucking companies might require additional coverage to meet specific regulations. While not mandatory, it’s advisable for personal vehicles used for work to be insured under hired and non-owned auto insurance (HNOA), since personal auto policies typically exclude business use. HNOA can be added to commercial general liability insurance or a business owner’s policy.

    >> Explore Next Solutions for Comprehensive Coverage >>

    Top 7 Companies for Small Business Insurance

    Next logo

    Next offers a lineup of commercial insurance policies that you can snag online and start leveraging immediately. They have a business owner’s policy that melds general liability with commercial property insurance. Plus, they toss in commercial auto insurance, workers’ comp, professional liability insurance, and even coverage for tools and equipment, among others.

    Next rolls out digital tools to streamline your policy management. These tools allow you to instantly share a live certificate of insurance and tack on additional insured parties at zero extra charge. You can opt for monthly payments and nab up to a 25% discount.

    Launched in 2016 and planted in Palo Alto, California, Next Insurance taps into artificial intelligence and machine learning to simplify the insurance buying experience. They flaunt an A- (Excellent) financial strength rating from AM Best, positioning them a cut above. Still, it’s worth mentioning that some rivals might offer specialized coverages like cyber liability insurance.

    With Next, you’re looking at securing various business insurance coverages online in roughly ten minutes. And if you prefer a human touch, you have the option to chat with an insurance advisor based in the U.S.

    Choosing Next in New York brings several advantages, like the quick sharing of a live insurance certificate, the ability to customize your business insurance with a range of coverages, and a fully online quote and application process, with extra help available when you need it.

    Read: NEXT Business Insurance Review

    >> Get Your Business Insured With Next! >>

    Hiscox logo

    Hiscox stands out as a prime choice for freelancers, celebrated as the top insurer for independent contractors among small commercial insurers. They offer a flexible business owner’s policy (BOP) that addresses a variety of needs, such as business interruption, electronic data loss, and professional liability insurance. 

    For freelancers, Hiscox tailors standalone professional and general liability policies perfect for short-term projects, and they feature handy monthly payment options.

    Hiscox boasts an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best, reflecting strong financial health. Although they’ve faced a higher-than-average volume of complaints in the past three years, the decreasing trend in complaints year-over-year suggests rising customer satisfaction. Hiscox’s policies, including their BOPs, are available starting at a budget-friendly $500 per year.

    In New York, Hiscox shines by providing substantial perks like tailored options for independent contractors, no-fee monthly payments, short-term liability insurance, and an entirely online quote and application process, all supported with readily available help.

    >> Get Your Business Insured With Hiscox! >>

    Simply Business Insurance logo

    Simply Business makes it easy to sift through quotes and coverage options from leading insurance providers like Hiscox, helping you pinpoint the best fit for your needs. You can pull up policy options online in less than ten minutes. If you need extra help or have questions, licensed agents are just a phone call away.

    This service is especially handy for businesses and individual proprietors. It customizes its insurance recommendations based on the unique aspects of your profession, whether that’s landscaping, accounting, or photography. While Simply Business doesn’t handle claims directly (that’s up to your chosen provider), it offers plenty of support, from retrieving new copies of your policy documents to helping you connect with your provider for any needed help.

    Key benefits of using Simply Business in New York include a swift quote process, access to licensed agents for guidance, and choices from top insurance providers.

    >> Get Insured With Simply Business Insurance! >>

    Tivly logo

    Tivly streamlines obtaining business insurance through a comprehensive online platform where you can quickly input your criteria and get a quote customized to your business needs. With partnerships with over 200 providers, including major players like Progressive, The Hartford, Tivly ensures you’re paired with the insurance provider that best safeguards your financial interests.

    With Tivly, you can access a variety of business insurance types, such as business income insurance and liability coverage, safeguarding your life’s work.

    The advantages of using Tivly in New York include a straightforward quote process, a vast network of over 200 partner providers, and the confidence of being matched with a provider that aligns with your specific business insurance requirements.

    >> Get Your Business Insured With Tivly! >>

    Coverwallet logo

    Shopping for business insurance can be a daunting and time-consuming endeavor, but CoverWallet makes it simpler by offering straightforward access to quotes from multiple insurers. You can start by chatting with an insurance advisor or directly getting quotes from renowned companies like Hiscox, and Progressive. 

    CoverWallet offers a range of coverage options, including workers’ compensation, general liability, and commercial property insurance, enabling you to customize protection for every facet of your business.

    After choosing your insurance, you can manage your policies via MyCoverWallet, an online dashboard that lets you issue insurance certificates, file claims, and handle premium payments, ensuring your policies are organized and readily accessible. Plus, you can always reach out to an expert for advice.

    CoverWallet also provides extensive educational resources tailored to various industries. These resources help you identify the recommended coverage based on your industry, location, workforce size, and annual revenue, simplifying finding the right insurance for your business.

    Key benefits of using CoverWallet in New York include the ease of obtaining multiple quotes, learning about industry-specific insurance suggestions, and access to a comprehensive range of insurance types.

    >> Get Your Business Insured With CoverWallet! >>

    Progressive is well-known as a dependable car insurance provider and stands out as a superb choice for businesses with commercial fleets. Trucking companies operating tractor-trailers and long-haul semi-trucks will particularly benefit from Progressive’s extensive coverage.

    Businesses with at least three years of operation can benefit from up to 5% savings on premiums. There’s a chance to secure a 15% discount on your commercial auto policy if you choose to pay the full premium upfront.

    Beyond vehicle insurance, Progressive provides an array of additional business insurance options. These include cyber insurance, professional liability, business owner policies, workers’ compensation, and general liability insurance. They also offer “any auto coverage,” which ensures protection for vehicles owned and operated for business by you or your team.

    The benefits of opting for Progressive in New York include adaptable coverage options tailored to your specific business requirements and the possibility of additional perks such as risk management services.

    >> Get Insured With Progressive Business Insurance! >>

    The Hartford logo

    The Hartford brings a wealth of expertise in business insurance, focusing on crafting policies that align precisely with the unique requirements of each client, which helps in cost savings. 

    They cater to a wide range of clients, from large corporations and mid-sized businesses to sole proprietors, offering a diverse array of policies. Their offerings include event insurance, employment practices liability, directors and officers insurance, bonding and surety, flood insurance, coverage for loss of business income, restaurant insurance, workers’ compensation, and technology errors and omissions, among others.

    Opting for The Hartford in New York benefits tapping into the company’s over 200 years of experience in the insurance industry. The company simplifies the process with online quote generation, upholds a strong financial rating, and provides a broad selection of commercial insurance products.

    >> Get Your Business Insured With Hartford! >>

    Types of Business Insurance Coverage Available in New York

    New York Business Owner’s Policy

    A Business Owners’ Policy (BOP) merges both business property and liability insurance into a unified policy. This coverage supports New York businesses and their workforce against various claims, such as:

    • Bodily injury
    • Property damage
    • Theft

    Moreover, you can tailor your BOP to suit the specific requirements of your business by incorporating additional policies like:

    • Data breach insurance
    • Professional liability insurance
    • Workers’ compensation insurance

    A BOP is particularly advisable if your business possesses:

    • A physical premises in New York, be it a retail store, a home office, a conventional office, or a leased area.
    • The likelihood of facing customer lawsuits due to injuries incurred at your business location.
    • Valuable digital assets, equipment, money, or furnishings that are at risk of being lost, damaged, or stolen.

    New York Commercial Property Insurance

    If you run a business in New York, securing your assets is paramount. This is where commercial property insurance steps in, providing a safety net for:

    • Your gear
    • Inventory stash
    • Office Decor
    • Personal belongings

    Imagine a fire wreaking havoc in your workspace, burning through your products or gear. This coverage not only aids in repairs or replacements but also covers losses from theft or misplacement of office equipment. We also tailor policies to fit your specific needs, safeguarding valuable papers or records.

    General Liability Insurance in NY

    Known also as business liability insurance, general liability insurance in New York shields your venture from various claims, such as:

    • Reputational damage
    • Physical damage to property
    • Bodily harm
    • Advertising blunders

    So, if your advertisement misfires or someone gets hurt on your premises, this insurance has got your back, covering potential liabilities.

    New York Business Income Insurance

    Should a mishap like fire, theft, or storm force your business doors to shut, business income insurance steps in to help recover the lost revenue during downtime. Here’s when you might consider this coverage essential:

    • If your business operates out of a physical location, whether owned or rented
    • If you run a retail store
    • If your revenue depends heavily on software or digital assets
    • If your business uses machinery or tools to produce goods or provide services

    We offer business income insurance as part of our Business Owners’ Policy (BOP). However, you can purchase it separately too.

    Errors and Omissions Insurance in New York

    Also known as professional liability insurance, errors and omissions coverage is vital for safeguarding your business against claims such as:

    • Negligence
    • Misrepresentation
    • Giving incorrect advice
    • Not delivering professional services or making errors in providing them
    • Libel or slander
    • Not securing personally identifiable information

    Lacking this type of insurance could mean facing hefty legal defense costs on your own.

    Cost of Small Business Insurance in NY

    Are you a small business owner trying to figure out your insurance expenses? Here’s a breakdown of the average costs for small business insurance in New York:

    • General liability: $41 monthly
    • Workers’ compensation: $37 monthly
    • Professional liability/Errors and Omissions: $70 monthly

    These figures apply to businesses both in New York City and across the state. Factors influencing these costs include:

    • The nature of your industry and associated risks
    • The scope of your business operations
    • How many employees do you have
    • The limits of your policy and the deductibles

    >> Ensure Your Business’s Future With Next >>

    Frequently Asked Questions – Small Business Insurance New York

    >> Check Out Next >>

    Bottom Line

    Small business insurance in New York is a vital safeguard for businesses, protecting against various risks and uncertainties inherent in today’s economic landscape. Whether it’s liability coverage, property damage, or worker’s compensation, the right insurance policy provides not only peace of mind but also a solid foundation for growth and stability. 

    As such, New York small business owners are encouraged to carefully assess their specific needs and seek tailored insurance solutions to ensure their enterprise thrives in the competitive market.

    >> Explore Next Solutions for Comprehensive Coverage >>