Sections of this topic
Welcome to the fascinating realm of Limited Liability Companies (LLCs), where managing your business takes center stage. Imagine this: you’ve decided to embark on an entrepreneurial journey. Now, you face the crucial question of how your LLC should be managed.
Should you go for a member-managed structure, where all owners actively participate in daily operations? Or maybe a manager-managed setup, where designated individuals handle day-to-day affairs while members focus on the bigger picture?
Join us as we explore the captivating world of member-managed versus manager-managed LLCs. We’ll dive into the nuances, advantages, and factors that shape this vital decision. Get ready to gain clarity and make informed choices to guide your business toward success.
Who Owns the LLC?
The owners of an LLC are called members. You can think of members as partners or shareholders in a corporation. If your LLC has managers, members are more like shareholders and won’t be involved in the daily management.
If your LLC doesn’t have managers, members act more like partners, having a direct say in decision-making. This distinction helps define each member’s level of involvement and responsibility within the company.
Management of an LLC
A member-managed LLC differs from a manager-managed LLC based on the relationship between ownership and management. An LLC is unique because it can choose one of two management structures: managed by its members or by designated managers (who can be third-party individuals).
According to state law, member management is the default rule. This means that if managers aren’t selected in the Articles of Organization, members will direct the affairs of the LLC. However, the LLC can state in its Articles or operating agreement that a manager or managers will manage it.
This arrangement gives the manager authority over daily operations, such as hiring employees, issuing payments, and entering into contracts. The LLC’s owners retain authority over strategic business decisions, like applying for credit and forming business partnerships.
>> Use ZenBusiness to Start an LLC >>
How Does a Member-Managed LLC Work
A member-managed LLC is a business entity where all members participate in decision-making. Each member has an equal right to manage the LLC’s business unless the operating agreement states otherwise. If a dispute arises, the majority vote decides the outcome, though some actions may require unanimous consent.
With the members’ consent, an LLC can be set up with different classes of members. This means one class might have more or distinct management rights than others. This flexibility allows for tailored management structures that suit the business’s and its members’ specific needs.
Reasons to Choose a Member-Managed LLC
While each situation is unique, here are some scenarios where you might prefer a member-managed LLC:
- The members want to participate in day-to-day management actively
- The LLC has only a small number of members, making it easy to make management decisions without needing extensive consultations
- The members are well-acquainted with the business and can make informed decisions
These situations allow for streamlined operations and hands-on involvement from those most invested in the company’s success.
Rights and Responsibilities of LLC Members
LLC members have several important rights and responsibilities, including:
- Financial Rights: Members share in the company’s profits and losses. They also receive distributions of the LLC’s assets. The operating agreement defines the nature of these financial rights, which might be shared equally based on capital contributions or by other criteria. Even though members manage the business, they do not own the LLC’s property.
- Right to Vote: Voting rights vary depending on the management structure. In a member-managed LLC, members vote on all business matters. In a manager-managed LLC, members have limited voting power. The operating agreement should detail all voting-related rules, such as meeting locations and quorum requirements.
- Member Inspections: Some states require LLCs to maintain records and allow members to inspect them. These records include each member’s names, addresses, contributions, and shares of profits and losses, as well as managers’ names and addresses and certain tax records. If the LLC wants to restrict or expand members’ inspection rights, this should be specified in the operating agreement.
- Liability of Members: A key feature of an LLC is that members aren’t liable for the company’s debts or obligations. However, they must make the required capital contributions, and penalties for failing to do so are outlined in the operating agreement.
Pros of Manager-Managed LLC
- Enables swift operations for larger LLCs
- Facilitates passive investment for investors, simplifying involvement in the business
- Empowers active managers to make efficient decisions without requiring unanimous owner consensus
- Centralizes decision-making authority, avoiding potential complications from too many decision-makers
Cons of Manager-Managed LLC
- Some owners may feel excluded from managerial decisions
- Requires detailed documentation of the manager’s authority in the operating agreement
- A professional manager may lack the depth of understanding about the business compared to the owners
- The necessity to provide a salary for a professional manager can strain finances, particularly for smaller businesses
What If the LLC Has One Owner (Single-Member LLC)?
Many small businesses operate as single-member LLCs with one member or owner. These LLCs often choose to be member-managed. For federal tax purposes, a single-member LLC is considered a “disregarded entity,” which still offers asset protection.
Business income and expenses are reported on Schedule C, which is then included with the owner’s personal IRS Form 1040. This setup simplifies tax filing while maintaining the benefits of limited liability.
>> Use ZenBusiness to Start an LLC >>
How Does a Manager-managed LLC Work
As mentioned earlier, members don’t engage in the daily management of a manager-managed LLC. Instead, managers handle these business decisions. A member can also serve as a manager, much like a shareholder can be a director in a corporation. Alternatively, an outsider can be appointed as the manager.
In a manager-managed LLC, the business operates similarly to a corporation, with a central governing body deciding without needing members’ consent first. Managers may oversee daily operations or appoint officers to handle these tasks.
The operating agreement should specify the number of managers and their qualifications. This ensures clarity and sets the framework for efficient management within the LLC.
Reasons to Choose a Manager-Managed LLC
A manager-managed LLC can be smart if certain members, like family members or outside investors, don’t want to be involved in decision-making. With this setup, these members won’t have a say in the daily business decisions aimed at achieving your company’s goals.
As noted earlier, LLC managers can be either members/owners or third-party individuals, though the latter is uncommon in small LLCs.
This management style is often preferred when some or all members wish to remain passive investors, when the LLC has many members, or when the members lack the necessary management expertise or familiarity with the business.
This allows for professional management while still benefiting from the members’ investment and support.
Rights and Responsibilities of Managers
The LLC operating agreement outlines details of a manager’s rights and responsibilities. It includes stipulations about meeting locations, quorum, voting, and notice requirements. It also specifies whether videoconferencing participation is allowed, whether committees will be formed, and how vacancies will be filled.
Here is a breakdown of the typical rights and responsibilities of an LLC manager:
- Fiduciary Duties: Whether members or outside managers manage your LLC, these individuals owe special duties to the LLC and its members, known as fiduciary duties. These duties include acting in the LLC’s and its members’ best interests, maintaining loyalty, and avoiding conflicts of interest.
- Liability of Managers: Managers aren’t liable for the LLC’s debts and obligations. However, they can be held liable to the LLC or its members for breaches of fiduciary duty or the operating agreement or for voting for unlawful distribution of the LLC’s assets.
- Indemnification: Managers may have financial protection against expenses and liabilities incurred in defending themselves against claims based on their conduct. This indemnification protection may be required or permitted by state LLC statutes. Some states mandate indemnification, while others give the LLC the authority to indemnify its managers and members. The operating agreement should outline the circumstances under which the LLC will indemnify managers and members.
These provisions help ensure managers are held accountable while also protecting them from undue legal risks, promoting responsible management within the LLC.
Pros of Member-Managed LLC
- Ideal option for brick-and-mortar businesses like retailers
- Every member holds influence over management choices
- A simpler structure is especially beneficial for small enterprises
Cons of Member-Managed LLC
- Raising capital from investors becomes challenging under this structure
- Managing the LLC can demand significant time, diverting owners from strategic planning
Can a Single-Member LLC Be Manager-Managed?
If you, as an owner or member, decide that you don’t want to manage the LLC, you can opt for a manager-managed structure. For instance, if your LLC owns a series of restaurants, you might appoint a manager for each location to handle operations, manage employees, and oversee inventory.
These responsibilities are detailed in your operating agreement and the Articles of Organization. This approach lets you focus on broader business strategies while ensuring each restaurant runs smoothly under competent management.
Document Your LLC Management Choice
If you opt for member management, you might not need to document this choice formally. However, many states require you to specify whether your LLC will be member-managed or manager-managed in the Articles of Organization when forming your LLC.
Regardless, all LLCs should have a written operating agreement. This document defines the basic rights and responsibilities of the members (and managers, if applicable). Having a clear operating agreement helps prevent misunderstandings and ensures the smooth operation of the LLC.
How to Choose? – Member-Managed vs Manager-Managed LLC
Choosing between a member-managed and manager-managed LLC depends on your business’s specific circumstances.
If you have family investors or multiple owners, a manager-managed LLC centralizes decision-making authority in a few key individuals, simplifying the process.
This structure is particularly beneficial for larger LLCs where coordinating among every member for each business decision could be more practical. It streamlines operations and ensures consistent management.
A member-managed LLC is often the simplest choice for small businesses with two or three co-owners. It allows owners to divide management responsibilities among themselves, giving them greater influence over the business’s direction, which many entrepreneurs prefer.
This structure works well when specialized expertise is crucial for the business. For example, owning a pawn shop, like Steven Sinatra’s, requires extensive knowledge and challenging skills. With member management, owners can run the business according to their preferences and address issues promptly.
In summary, the choice between member-managed and manager-managed LLCs depends on the number of owners, desired decision-making processes, and the need for specialized expertise within the business. Each structure offers unique advantages tailored to different business needs.
Consulting a Business Attorney
Early on, deciding how your LLC will be run and managed is a significant decision. If you and your co-owners have worked together before or have experience managing a business, you can likely make this decision independently.
However, consulting a business lawyer is wise if you and your co-owners have different business interests or need legal guidance on dividing management roles and responsibilities.
An attorney can help you draft an operating agreement and advise on the best legal organization for your business. This ensures that your LLC is set up effectively, with clear roles and responsibilities, paving the way for smooth operations and future success.
>> Use ZenBusiness to Start an LLC >>
Member-Managed vs Manager-Managed LLC – Frequently Asked Questions
Bottom Line on Member-Managed vs Manager Managed LLC
In conclusion, deciding between a member-managed and manager-managed LLC comes down to your business’s unique needs and dynamics. Consider factors like the number of owners or investors, their desired level of involvement, and the specialized expertise needed.
A manager-managed structure benefits larger LLCs by centralizing decision-making and streamlining operations. Conversely, a member-managed LLC gives individual owners greater control and flexibility, especially in smaller businesses or those requiring specialized knowledge.
Regardless of your option, it’s essential to consult with legal and business professionals to ensure compliance and make informed decisions. Take the time to assess your specific circumstances and align your LLC’s management structure with your long-term goals.
>> Use ZenBusiness to Start an LLC >>
Related Articles
- Start a Limited Liability Company
- Best Business Registration Services
- Doing Business As
- Registered Agent
- Best LLC Services
- Register a Business
Business License
Larry is a finance graduate and entrepreneur who loves educating others on various business software through his own experiences. Larry loves to write about all topics, from fashion editorials to tax advice. On his days off, you can find him at a basketball court or gym working up a sweat.
